National Inclusion Commission Acting Chair Hari Datta Joshi Mocks Transgender People
The irony was stark: speaking at the launch of the Breaking Barriers project, supported by the European Union & Action Aid Nepal, the leadership of a constitutional body mandated to dismantle structural exclusion chose instead to erect new ones.
Addressing the event, Hari Datta Joshi, Acting Chairperson of the National Inclusion Commission (NIC), began by lamenting that while the commission carries the overarching responsibility for inclusion, its definition and jurisdiction remain plagued by a lack of clarity. Yet, instead of using that institutional ambiguity to urge expansive constitutional protection, Joshi used the platform to police boundaries and demean transgender and gender-diverse people.
Dismissing gender identity as arbitrary caprice, Joshi remarked:
“Now, if one feels like being a man one minute they become a man, and if they feel like being a woman the next they become a woman, and they proudly boast about obtaining up to four citizenship certificates. This only invites aberration; rights cannot be achieved this way.”
This statement is not just an embarrassing contradiction at an event themed around breaking barriers; it is a fundamental assault on constitutional guarantees, legal precedent, and administrative reality.
From “Lack of Clarity” to Active Delegitimization
Joshi conceded that the National Inclusion Commission struggles with a lack of clarity regarding its mandate and the precise definitions of inclusion. However, instead of engaging with legal scholarship or the lived experiences of marginalized groups to resolve this ambiguity, he chose to scapegoat transgender people.
If a constitutional body lacks conceptual clarity on inclusion, the remedy is rigorous alignment with Article 12, Article 18, and Article 42 of the Constitution of Nepal—not publicly ridiculing the very groups the state has historically excluded.
Trivializing Gender Identity and Self-Determination
Joshi’s comparison of gender transition to an impulsive, minute-to-minute whim demonstrates a willful ignorance of gender self-determination. Gender identity is an innate, foundational aspect of human personhood and dignity. Transition is neither casual nor flippant; it is a profound and demanding reality navigated in the face of deep societal stigma and pervasive institutional gatekeeping.
Reducing self-determination to a fleeting whim dismisses decades of legal precedent established by Nepal’s Supreme Court—beginning with the landmark 2007 Blue Diamond Society ruling and repeatedly upheld in verdicts since.
Blaming Trans Citizens for Bureaucratic Incompetence
Accusing individuals of creating “aberrations” (bikriti) by obtaining “up to four citizenship certificates” fundamentally misrepresents the administrative nightmare transgender Nepalis endure. Transgender individuals do not seek multiple certificates out of bad faith; they are forced through repeated rectifications because of the Ministry of Home Affairs’ conflicting circulars, arbitrary local demands for invasive medical certifications, and bureaucratic harassment at District Administration Offices. Calling these agonizing attempts to secure legal personhood an “aberration” reverses victim and perpetrator, deflecting blame away from an incompetent state apparatus onto marginalized citizens.
The Zero-Sum Trap: Human Rights Are Not Rationed
Joshi also pointed to the disability rights movement—noting that classification demands expanded from two to fourteen categories—to argue that growing sub-identities and classifications within the LGBTIQ+ movement create disorder. This logic relies on a regressive scarcity mindset. Civil rights are not a rationed commodity. Acknowledging diverse sub-identities does not dilute systemic advocacy; it ensures that legal protections are precise enough to prevent vulnerable subgroups from slipping through administrative cracks.
Joshi’s attempt to use the disability rights movement as a cautionary tale—pointing to the expansion from two categories of allowance to fourteen types of classification as an example of demands getting out of hand—is just as revealing. Expanding disability classifications was not administrative excess; it was the hard-won result of decades of advocacy to ensure that distinct groups, from individuals with psychosocial disabilities to autism and hemophilia, received appropriate accommodations rather than being erased under a blunt, one-size-fits-all label.
By framing this progress as a slippery slope, Joshi reveals an austerity-driven charity mindset that sees human rights as a budgetary burden rather than an entitlement under the UN CRPD and Nepal’s Disability Rights Act. Pitting one marginalized group’s structural recognition against another to justify gatekeeping is an affront to both communities.
The Root Problem: An Inclusion Commission That Excludes
Joshi’s rhetoric cannot be dismissed as an isolated personal blunder; it is the predictable outcome of an institution alienated from the very constituencies it was created to serve. Established under Part 27, Article 258 of the Constitution of Nepal, the NIC was designed to represent and safeguard communities facing historical, geographical, and social marginalization.
Yet, in practice, appointments to the NIC have systematically reproduced dominant power structures. Staffed predominantly by Khas-Arya men—often appointed through contentious political horse-trading rather than human rights expertise—the commission mirrors the very hegemony it was tasked to deconstruct. When a constitutional commission mandated to represent marginalized groups has virtually no representation of transgender persons, queer individuals, persons with disabilities, or intersectional women in its leadership, it ceases to be a bridge for the vulnerable. Instead, it becomes an echo chamber of institutional entitlement where commissioners treat marginalized lived experiences with paternalistic condescension.
A constitutional commission cannot credibly profess to stand “with activists at the policy level” while its head mocks the foundational rights of marginalized communities. At an event meant to break barriers, Hari Datta Joshi reinforced them.
The National Inclusion Commission must be held accountable to its constitutional purpose: eliminating structural discrimination, not policing and invalidating the identities of the people it exists to protect.
#NICFailsInclusion
#HoldJoshiAccountable
The footage was originally circulated by Pahichan Media, an outlet criticized for pushing anti-trans propaganda. (News Link)

Leave a Reply